Eldon, Missouri

Hey there—
got a car
that needs
some love?

Welcome to McCarty's Busted Knuckle Garage. We're your neighbors on 23rd Street, and we take care of your vehicle the way we'd want ours taken care of—honestly, thoroughly, and without the hassle.

Call Us Today Our Services
2697
23rd Street
Eldon
Missouri
All
Makes & Models
Mechanic working on a vehicle in a well-lit auto repair shop
Honest Work
No surprises, ever
Scroll
What We Do

Everything your car needs,
right here.

From routine maintenance to unexpected repairs, we handle it all with care and transparency. No job is too big or too small when you're dealing with neighbors who actually know cars.

General Repair

Engine diagnostics, brake service, suspension work, and everything in between. We diagnose it right the first time.

Oil Changes

Quick, clean oil changes using quality fluids. We'll top off the rest and make sure everything's running smooth.

Brake Service

Squeaky brakes? We hear you. Pad replacements, rotor resurfacing, and full brake system inspections.

Tire Service

Rotations, alignments, flat repairs, and new tire installations. We'll get you rolling safely again.

Check Engine

That light on your dash doesn't stand a chance. We'll read the codes, find the problem, and fix it for good.

Pre-Purchase Inspections

Buying a used car? Bring it by first. We'll give you an honest rundown before you hand over any money.

Interior of McCarty's Busted Knuckle Garage showing a clean, organized auto repair workspace
About Us

Built on hard work and a handshake.

McCarty's Busted Knuckle Garage isn't fancy—and we don't pretend to be. We're a straightforward auto repair shop right here in Eldon, and we've built our reputation the same way we fix cars: one honest job at a time.

When you pull into our bay, you're not a ticket number. We'll look at what's going on, explain it to you in plain English, and only do the work you actually need. If something doesn't need replacing yet, we'll tell you that too.

We service all makes and models—domestic and import—because a car is a car, and every driver deserves to get home safely.

All Makes & Models
Transparent Pricing
No Surprise Fees
Why Choose Us

The kind of garage
you actually want
to visit.

You Deal With Us, Directly

No call centers, no transfer scripts. When you call or walk in, you talk to the people who actually work on your car.

Fair & Upfront Pricing

We give you an estimate before we touch anything. If we find something else while we're in there, we call you first—no add-ons without your go-ahead.

Quality Parts, Proper Job

We use reliable parts and take the time to do it right. Cutting corners helps nobody—not you, and not us.

Your Neighbors, Not a Chain

We're right here in Eldon. We care about our reputation because we see you at the grocery store on Monday morning.

Get In Touch

Give us a ring.
We'll take care of it.

Whether it's a check engine light, a strange noise, or just an oil change reminder—call us or drop by the shop. We're easy to talk to and we'll get you sorted.

(319) 931-5921 Send an Email
Find Us

Come say hello.

Our Location

2697 23rd St
Eldon, MO 52554-8002

Hours
Monday – Friday 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Saturday By Appointment
Sunday Closed
Is this your business?This is my business